Manual vs automatic transmission is a classic debate among car owners. Manual transmission vehicles cater to passionate drivers looking to clutch through different gears and better control their acceleration. Meanwhile, automatic transmission vehicles offer more convenience to commuters and drivers who value simpler operations.

However, did you know these two transmission types also differ in insurance costs? Stick around as we delve into the difference in insurance costs between manual vs automatic cars.

Find Cheap Auto Insurance

Manual vs Automatic Transmission - A Brief Comparison

Before driving right into the differences in insurance costs, let's overview the key differences between manual and automatic vehicles:


The most apparent distinction is the transmission itself. Manual cars rely on drivers to manually shift gears using a clutch, providing full control over gear changes. Conversely, automatic vehicles manage gear changes independently, eliminating the need for manual gear shifting.


Manual vehicles are typically more cost-effective due to a relatively lower upfront price tag. Many manufacturers offer manual transmission in their base trims. Hence, they're more budget-friendly and ideal for drivers prioritizing economy over convenience.

3.Fuel Economy

Manuals have been known for offering better fuel efficiency as drivers control gear shifts. However, modern automatic transmission technologies like CVTs and dual-clutch systems have almost closed the fuel efficiency gap.

4.Driving Experience

Driving experience is a key factor when choosing between automatic and manual vehicles. Car enthusiasts prefer manuals since they offer a more engaging experience through gear shifts. Meanwhile, drivers who drive regularly, especially in high-traffic areas, prefer automatic cars due to ease of operations.

Manual vs Automatic Cars - Understanding the Insurance Cost Differences

In the battle of the gears, manual transmission vehicles often win the insurance affordability race. Below are the key factors that contribute to the difference in insurance costs between manual and automatic cars:

1.Vehicle Market Value

Manuals are typically less expensive than their automatic counterparts. Hence, they have a lower market value. Since vehicle market value is a key factor determining insurance premiums, manual vehicles typically have an advantage in affordability. Drivers who own manual vehicles usually pay less for comprehensive and collision coverage, as the lower price tag reduces the financial risk for insurers.

2.Driving Behavior

Manual drivers, especially older adults between 30-50, are more attentive and responsible on the road since gear shifts require more focus and engagement. Hence, they have a lower risk profile in the eyes of auto insurance companies.
Manual drivers are safer and more likely to exhibit defensive driving behaviors. The ability to control gear shifts can also improve reactions in extreme driving conditions. However, drivers owning manual coupes, roadsters, or supercars could be required to pay a higher premium since they're more susceptible to reckless driving behavior and accidents.

3.Accident Risk

Manual vehicles, in general, are less prone to accidents. The added control in operations increases focus and alertness. Moreover, manual drivers must have their hands on the steering wheel and gearshift, making them less susceptible to distractions like texting. This often leads to better response times, quick decision-making, and lower risk of collisions - all factors that lower insurance costs.

4.Custom Safety Features

Many manual car owners opt for custom features to improve vehicle safety, including advanced braking systems, airbag upgrades, and lighting modifications. Investing in these extras allows them to mitigate several road safety risks, reducing the chances of crashes or collisions. As a result, car insurance companies may reduce insurance rates to appreciate the driver's commitment to safe driving.

5.Driver Demographics

Demographics also plays a crucial role in manual vs automatic transmission insurance costs. People who typically purchase manual vehicles are older and have more driving experience. Statistically, older drivers have a better driving record with fewer violations, tickets, or accidents. This experience improves their risk profile, prompting auto insurance providers to offer more favorable rates than automatic drivers.

6.Repair and Maintenance Costs

Manual transmission vehicles generally incur lower repair and maintenance expenses. The manual transmission is a simpler system with fewer components, reducing the chances of mechanical failures. Additionally, manual drivers may be more inclined to perform regular maintenance and repairs and even deal with minor issues without professional intervention. As a result, they can control upkeep expenses and address issues proactively, reducing accidents caused by vehicle malfunctions. Many car insurance companies appreciate this commitment to maintenance and reward drivers with reduced premiums.

Which Transmission Should You Choose?

Choosing between a manual and automatic vehicle based on insurance cost differences can be difficult. Here are some factors to consider to simplify and accelerate your decision:


Opt for a manual vehicle if you're on a tight budget or have a relatively low income. The lower purchase price and potential insurance savings make manuals a smarter choice.

2.Resale Value

Automatic vehicles generally have better resale values due to higher market demand. Hence, the initial savings from a manual vehicle might not be as high as the resale value of an automatic.

3.Insurance Profile

If you haven't purchased a vehicle yet, look for quotes for automatic and manual vehicles, preferably of the same make and model. Ensure you compare the differences based on your driving record, experience, and insurance profile.

4.Commute and Traffic

Consider your daily commute and local traffic conditions. If you frequently encounter high traffic, an automatic vehicle can reduce the physical strain of constant gear shifting, making your commute more comfortable. Prioritizing cost management over convenience by opting for a manual can backfire, as it often leads to road rage and frustration due to constant gear changes, increasing the risk of accidents.

Final Word

Regardless of your preferred transmission (manual or automatic), you must purchase an auto insurance coverage policy to legally operate your vehicle and protect it from financial damage due to accidents or other issues. Understanding the difference in insurance costs between manual vs automatic transmission could help you in various aspects of ownership, from purchase to operation and maintenance.

So, do your homework and choose wisely. Once you've decided, use BindRight's game-changing search and comparison tool to find the best coverage policy for your needs, vehicle, transmission, and budget.

Find Cheap Auto Insurance